About This Blog

Summaries and analysis of recent Delaware court decisions concerning business-related litigation.

Morris James Blogs

Links

Court Of Chancery Explains Claims Available To LLC Members

CMS Investment Holdings LLC v. Castle, C.A. No. 9468-VCP (June 23, 2015)

This is an interesting decision because it explains what direct claims are available to investors in an LLC. More ›

Court Of Chancery Orders Dissolution Despite LLC Agreement Bar

Meyer Natural Foods LLC v. Duff, C.A. 9703-VCN (June 4, 2015)

This decision may answer the question of whether an LLC Agreement’s bar of dissolution without a member’s consent trumps the statutory remedy of court-ordered dissolution when the entity’s purpose cannot be achieved any longer. It concludes that dissolution is proper under the facts presented where the objecting member really had no good reason to object.

Court Of Chancery Upholds Cash Calls To Eliminate Minority Owner

CanCan Development LLC v. Manno, C.A. 6429-VCL (May 27, 2015)

This is a great decision on how to get rid of a minority owner in an LLC when she is disruptive. More ›

Court Of Chancery Enforces Manager Rights In LLC

Posted In LLC Agreements

2009 Caiola Family Trust v. PWA LLC, C.A. 8028-VCP (April 30, 2014)

The language of an LLC agreement is all important in determining what it permits. This decision illustrates that point by holding that, under the LLC agreement involved, a 90% owner cannot remove the LLC manager.  This seems counterintuitive.  But that is the lesson of LLC law - you get what you agree to even if it is odd.

Court Of Chancery Explains When A Lie Is Just A Lie

Posted In LLC Agreements

Touch Of Italy Salumeria & Pasticceria LLC v. Bascio, C.A. 8602-VCG (January 13, 2014)

In this case, the defendant quit his employment, lied to his co-owners about why and then set up a competing business.  However, the LLC agreement did not have any limitation on competing with it. As a result, while the court was quick to condemn the lie, it held that competing was permitted. This is an example of how people in business together often feel there are some unwritten ethical rules that a court will enforce even if they are not part of the parties' agreement.  At least in the area of competition, that is just not so. You need to get it in writing to enforce an obligation to not compete after some one leaves your employment. Of course, this does not mean that there are no fiduciary or other duties that may require a course of conduct not spelled out in writing.  Hence, this decision should not be read too broadly

Court Of Chancery Suggests Equity May Aid When Dissolution Waived

Posted In LLC Agreements

Huatuco v Satellite Heathcare, C.A. 8465-VCG (December 9, 2013)

As this decision affirms, it is possible to waive the right to a judicial dissolution in an LLC agreement. However, the decision also notes that the Court may use its equitable powers to remedy an abuse of power.  This possible "escape valve" may be hard to invoke given the respect the Delaware Courts have for the right to contract away one's rights in an LLC agreement.

Court Of Chancery Enforces Indemnification Rights Under LLC Agreement

Posted In LLC Agreements

Costantini v. Swiss Farm Story Acquisition LLC, C.A. 8613-VCG (September 5, 2013)

This decision holds that language in an LLC agreement that mirrors the indemnification language of the Delaware Corporation law will be interpreted the same way to mandate indemnification to a prevailing manager.

Court Of Chancery Continues To Explain Bad Faith

Posted In LLC Agreements

Stewart v. BF Bolthouse Holdco LLC, C.A. 8119-VCP (August 30, 2013)

The interplay between fiduciary duties and contractual obligations is often hard to understand.  Add to that the task of explaining the duty to act in good faith and deal fairly and the law is even more confusing. This decision does a good job of cutting through that problem to explain: (1) when a complaint alleges enough facts to state a claim for acting in bad faith, (2) when contractual obligations take the place of fiduciary duties, and (3) when the obligation to act fairly is not superseded by contract.

Court Of Chancery Explains How To Determine Memerbership Interests

Posted In LLC Agreements

Grove v. Brown, C.A. 6793-VCG (August 8, 2013)

This is an interesting decision because it explains what is the effect when a member fails to pay the consideration contemplated by the LLC operating agreement to obtain his membership interest.  The answer is determined by what the operating agreement says is the consequence, loss of interest or just a debt owed to the LLC.

This is also an example of what a mess may be created when parties try to do their own legal work in setting up an entity and working their way through disputes.

Supreme Court Broadly Upholds Fair Dealing Claims

Posted In LLC Agreements

Gerber v. Enterprise Products Holdings LLC, No. 46, 2012 (June 10, 2013)

This decision has big implications. In a line of past decisions, the Court of Chancery has upheld arguments that  an LLC agreement may define what constitutes "good faith" in such a way as to severely limit claims based on the implied duty of good faith and fair dealing.  Of course, that duty under the Delaware LLC Act cannot be eliminated in an LLC agreement.  But, by permitting drafters to define what constituted good faith, the trial courts came close to eliminating that duty.  No more.

Exactly what will constitute a violation of the duty of good faith and fair dealing is also implicated by this decision.  Conduct that may seem permitted by the LLC agreement may now be prohibited if done to take an action that the investors never would have agreed to had they thought of it when the LLC agreement was drafted. Time will have to tell what all this means.