10.31.24

Matrix Parent, Inc. v. Audax Mgmt. Co., C.A. No. N23C-10-212 MAA CCLD (Del. Super. Ct. June 27, 2024).

In this decision, the acquirers of a business brought fraud claims, arguing that the defendants controlled the target and sellers during a fraudulent scheme to overstate revenue. Because the individual defendants argued for dismissal on the basis that the Court did not have personal jurisdiction, the Court examined whether there was jurisdiction under Delaware’s LLC manager consent statute. See 6 Del. C. § 18-109. The plaintiffs argued that the defendants were subject to jurisdiction because, while they were not “managers” as defined in the statute, they nonetheless were high-ranking employees with titles, respectively, of “managing director,” “partner,” and “principal.” The Court rejected this argument, however, and reasoned that holding a title was insufficient without allegations that the defendants participated materially in the management of the entity. The Court similarly rejected arguments based on the fact that the defendants were statutory “managers” of a different, affiliated Delaware limited liability company, because the plaintiffs’ claims did not focus on that entity or any alleged decisions by the defendants in managing it. 

In addition, the Court also rejected certain of the defendants’ arguments that non-recourse and exclusive remedy provisions in the governing Stock Purchase Agreement prevented fraud claims against non-signatories. The Court summarized precedent, including ABRY Partners V, L.P. v. F&W Acq. LLC, 891 A.2d 1032 (Del. Ch. 2006) and its progeny. The Court reasoned that a contract cannot bar fraud claims when the contract was procured by fraud and the defendants were knowingly complicit in the fraud. Accordingly, the Court rejected the non-signatory defendants’ arguments for dismissal on that basis. 

Array ( [0] => [email protected] [1] => [email protected] )

Featured Attorneys

Samuel Bashman

Related Service