During the defendant director’s tenure with the plaintiff company, he purchased stock of a direct competitor but did not disclose the investment to the company. Subsequently, the defendant resigned from the company to become the Executive Chair at the competitor. The sole question before the Court was whether the defendant’s failure to disclose his passive investment breached the duty of loyalty. The Court post-trial found no breach because the defendant obtained no operational control or input. The Court also accepted the defendant’s statement that he invested due to feelings of guilt from having reneged on his acceptance of the competitor’s prior offer to join the company as its CEO and instead remaining at the company. The plaintiff conceded there was no breach from making the investment, rather than failing to disclose it. The Court found, however, the absence of a conflict or bad faith conduct inimical to the company’s best interests precluded a duty to disclose in the circumstances. Accordingly, the Court ruled in favor of the defendant.