09.05.24

NGL Energy Partners LP v. LCT Cap., LLC, No. 265, 2023 (Del. May 28, 2024)
Appellee/cross-appellant (“LCT”) provided financial advisory services to appellants/cross-appellees (“NGL”) for a corporate acquisition without an agreement on compensation. LCT filed suit in the Delaware Superior Court after the parties could not reach a consensus on payment terms. Following a trial and an appeal, the court held a trial on damages for LCT's quantum meruit claim. The court made evidentiary rulings, including on expert testimony. The jury rendered a $36 million verdict in LCT's favor. The court calculated prejudgment interest and a per diem amount of post-judgment interest due only on the $36 million verdict, not also on the prejudgment interest owed. NGL appealed the court's evidentiary rulings, and LCT cross-appealed the court's decision not to accrue post-judgment interest on the prejudgment interest.

The Supreme Court affirmed the Superior Court’s evidentiary rulings for the reasons the latter had explained in its own ruling. The Supreme Court noted that the trial court’s jury instructions had warned against calculating damages in the way that NGL opposed. On LCT’s cross-appeal, the Supreme Court reversed the Superior Court. The Supreme Court explained that post-judgment interest accruing on prejudgment interest is not a form of compounding, but instead is a recognition that prejudgment interest is considered part of the “judgment” in a civil action and included within the statutory entitlement to post-judgment interest. The Supreme Court pointed to similar holdings in federal case law on the basis of the parallel federal statute and noted the policy rationale that post-judgment interest on prejudgment interest can encourage judgment debtors to promptly pay the full measure of their adjudicated obligations.

Array ( [0] => [email protected] [1] => [email protected] )

Featured Attorneys

Related Service