The plaintiff was a purchaser of a business who alleged that the business's lame-duck fiduciaries entered into a side deal to a gas-gathering agreement in violation of their fiduciary duties. The Court of Chancery held that the plaintiff's breach of fiduciary duty claims against the defendants in connection with their alleged covert side deal were barred by laches.
Claims for breach of fiduciary duty are governed by a three-year statute of limitations under Delaware law. Here, the fiduciary duty claims were brought six years after the side deal that the plaintiff challenged. The plaintiff claimed, however, that it had no knowledge of the alleged side deal until arbitration discovery revealed the existence of the side deal. The arbitration panel found that the plaintiff was nevertheless obligated to comply with obligations in the side deal and entered an arbitration award against the plaintiff, concluding that the plaintiff was in breach of the gas-gathering agreement. The Court ruled that the plaintiff's tolling argument was an improper collateral attack on the arbitration proceedings' core conclusion, and the arbitration award could not be set aside. Accordingly, without tolling, the Court found that the plaintiff's fiduciary duty claims were barred by laches.