09.19.24


Aldrich Cap. Partners Fund, LP v. Bray, C.A. No. 2023-1253-PRW (Del. Ch. May 17, 2024)

The plaintiff, an investment fund, purchased a healthcare technology company (“Rhythm”) that utilized a proprietary software platform to enable remote medical monitoring. The defendant was the founder of the company. Discovering during due diligence that another company (“Murj”) was suing Rhythm for breach of license agreements, the plaintiff bargained for representations and a Murj-specific indemnification in the stock purchase agreement. The representations included that Rhythm owned all its intellectual property and had not violated others’ intellectual property. The SPA specifically disclosed the Murj litigation but included inconsistent language as to whether and how the disclosure modified the scope of the representations. Two years later, the plaintiff saw discovery in the Murj litigation, which included communications indicating Rhythm purposefully had developed its platform based on Murj’s platform. The plaintiff then sued the defendant in the Court of Chancery, alleging the SPA’s representations were fraudulent and that the defendant was in breach of the SPA by not complying with her indemnity obligations. The defendant released certain funds from escrow, mooting portions of the contract claim, and moved to dismiss.

 

The Court determined that the plaintiff had stated a claim for fraud. A reasonable interpretation of the SPA supported the plaintiff's argument that the disclosure of the Murj litigation did not modify Rhythm’s representations regarding intellectual property. At the pleadings stage, this reasonable interpretation was sufficient to sustain the claim. The Court next rejected the defendant's argument that it was inconceivable she knew Rhythm had misappropriated intellectual property or violated its licensing agreement with Murj; the plaintiff’s complaint contained allegations of the defendant’s hands-on involvement at Rhythm, including efforts to use Murj’s platform as a template for developing a similar platform for Rhythm. The Court also rejected the defendant's argument that the Court should dismiss the fraud claim because the defendant could not possibly have known the truth as to representations of the legal conclusion that Rhythm had not breached agreements. The Court explained that a final judgment in parallel litigation was not a prerequisite for stating a claim for fraudulent representations of legal compliance, as it is reasonable to assume that people know whether their actions violate their contractual obligations. Lastly, the Court determined that the plaintiff had stated a claim for breach of the SPA, as the differing interpretations of the defendant’s SPA obligations beyond the escrow amount could not be resolved at the pleadings stage.

Array ( [0] => [email protected] [1] => [email protected] )

Featured Attorneys

Related Service