01.27.25

Conlon v. CGI Mfg. Buyer, LLC, C.A. No. N23C-11-151 EMD CCLD (Del. Super. Aug. 8, 2024) 

The Delaware Superior Court dismissed a tortious interference with contract claim based on the affiliate privilege doctrine. The plaintiffs, sellers of a business, claimed that the acquirer’s ultimate controller interfered with the earnout provisions in a purchase contract with the acquirer. 

The Court reviewed the elements of the tortious interference claim: (1) the existence of a contract, (2) of which the defendant knew, (3) an intentional act that is a significant factor in causing the breach of such contract, (4) without justification, (5) which caused injury. The Court specifically focused on the “non-straightforward” element – the lack of justification. The Court explained that it must balance the policies supporting tortious interference claims against a party’s legitimate right to compete as a part of doing business. The defendants claimed that this element could not be established because the parent was immunized from liability under Delaware’s affiliate privilege doctrine. The Court explained that in Delaware, the concept of corporate separateness supports a limited affiliate privilege, which protects a parent from tortious interference claims when the parent pursues its subsidiaries' profit-making activities in good faith. Thus, to overcome this protection, a plaintiff must demonstrate bad faith on the parent’s part. The Court explained that the parent could lawfully pursue activities that reasonably redirect resources between its subsidiaries. By contrast, bad faith could be demonstrated where a plaintiff established that the parent took actions that both induced the breach of a contract and rendered the subsidiary unable to satisfy its contractual obligations. Thus, because the seller-plaintiffs here did not establish that the parent acted without justification, the Court granted the defendant's motion to dismiss.  

Array ( [0] => [email protected] [1] => [email protected] )

Featured Attorneys

Samuel Bashman

Related Service