In this case, stockholders of Fox argued that Fox’s board of directors and some of its senior officers were aware that Fox News’ statements about fraud in the 2020 presidential election were actually false and defamatory, but they consciously prioritized profits over legal compliance. The defendants moved to dismiss under Rule 23.1 and argued that a demand upon the board would not have been futile. The Court of Chancery disagreed and held that the complaint alleged particularized facts to support a reasonable inference that one of the directors, Rupert Murdoch, faced a substantial risk of liability for breaching his duty of loyalty by consciously deciding to have the company air defamatory content. The Court further found that at least three other directors of the eight-member board lacked independence from Murdoch. Specifically, one director was not independent because he was Murdoch’s son, and the allegations also supported an inference that he consciously caused or permitted the company to broadcast statements that were unfounded or defamatory. The Court also found the plaintiffs sufficiently alleged that two additional directors were not independent due to longstanding business and personal relationships with Murdoch, which the Court agreed could cause them to feel gratitude and a sense of indebtedness to Murdoch. As a result, at least half of the board was not disinterested and independent, and a demand would be futile. The Court accordingly denied the defendants’ motions to dismiss.