blog
By Medical Malpractice Attorney Ryan T. Keating
A hospital’s outreach after a bad medical outcome is rarely random. The contact usually comes from a member of the patient’s medical team, a hospital executive, or a risk manager or patient safety representative, and they may offer a promise to begin an investigation into what went wrong, or ask to set up a meeting to talk through what happened. Reaching that stage means someone at the hospital has likely already reviewed the case internally and decided it’s worth a direct conversation with you.
For a family already carrying grief and a long list of unanswered questions, that can be a lot to absorb on top of everything else. The hospital already has a team looking out for its interests throughout this process, and it is worth having someone doing the same for you. This article covers why hospitals initiate this kind of contact, what it actually signals about fault, and what you are required to do once they reach out.
Many hospitals have a structured process they follow when a patient has a serious or unexpected outcome. Some give it a formal name, like CANDOR. Others run the same kind of process through their risk management or patient safety department without naming it at all.
These Hospital Disclosure Programs exist because hospitals have increasingly moved away from staying silent after something goes wrong. Research on patient safety has shown that early, honest communication tends to preserve trust between patients and providers, and helps hospitals improve future care. These programs can, in some circumstances, provide the patient and their family members some direct benefits, but they also provide the hospital an opportunity to manage its own legal exposure, since structured, early communication tends to reduce the likelihood that patients and their families will pursue legal action. A hospital can genuinely want to be transparent with you and still be following a process that protects its own interests at the same time.
What tends to trigger this outreach: an unexpected complication during surgery, a medication or dosing error, a hospital-acquired infection, a birth injury, a diagnosis that was missed or came too late, or a death the hospital didn’t expect given the patient’s condition. Usually, the hospital reaches out because the event crossed its own internal threshold for review.
Not necessarily, and this is one of the most misunderstood parts of the process. Reaching out means the hospital’s internal review flagged the event as worth reviewing. That’s not the same as the hospital admitting a mistake caused harm.
During these conversations, hospital representatives often express regret or sympathy, sometimes something close to an apology. Some states, including Delaware, have laws that protect medical providers’ statements in these situations. Under the Delaware compassionate communication statute, if a hospital employee expresses sympathy or says something like “I’m sorry” after an unexpected medical outcome, that statement can’t typically be used against the hospital in a lawsuit. But if that same person goes further and admits a mistake actually happened, that part isn’t protected. So a hospital representative telling you that they’re sorry doesn’t, by itself, decide whether a malpractice claim succeeds.
None of this means you should distrust every kind word in that meeting. It just means sympathy and legal responsibility are being handled as two separate questions, even if the conversation never draws that line for you.
No. There’s no legal requirement to meet with a hospital’s disclosure team at all. Some families choose to engage with the process because it offers information they want, often with the help of an attorney. If you do decide to meet with the hospital, you’re not required to do it on their timeline. You can ask to reschedule, request a written summary of what will be discussed beforehand, or simply take the time you need to gather your thoughts, review your medical records, or talk with someone you trust first. Hospitals running structured disclosure programs see these kinds of requests often. Responding to the family’s needs and building trust is part of what the program is meant to do.
Every state also sets its own legal deadline for filing a medical malpractice claim, so it is important to understand that deadline as you work through the process.
Many families contact an attorney before meeting with the hospital’s disclosure team. An attorney can explain what to expect, review what you’ve already been told, and help you decide what to ask. This doesn’t have to be adversarial. It just means someone is looking out for your interests, not the hospital’s.
You can also bring an attorney with you to the meeting itself. Having someone there who understands the legal side of the conversation makes it easier to follow what’s being said and ask the right questions.
Continuing your care and looking into what happened are treated as separate matters. Hospitals have a professional and legal obligation to keep providing appropriate care regardless of whether a legal claim is involved, and the quality of your treatment isn’t supposed to change because of it.
That said, it’s still an uncomfortable position to be in, and it’s reasonable to want some distance from the team involved in what happened. If that discomfort is affecting your peace of mind, you can request a different attending physician or care team within the same hospital, or get a second opinion, without leaving the hospital or interrupting your care. If it runs deeper than that, transferring your care to a different hospital is also an option, though that’s a bigger decision worth thinking through on its own.
If you’re trying to understand what a hospital’s disclosure process means for you or a family member, the medical malpractice attorneys at Morris James can talk through what you’ve been told and what happens next. Call 302.888.6857 for a free consultation. You pay nothing unless we recover money for you.
These programs can, in some circumstances, provide the patient and their family members some direct benefits, but they also provide the hospital an opportunity to manage its own legal exposure.
