About This Blog

Summaries and analysis of recent Delaware court decisions concerning business-related litigation.

Morris James Blogs

Links

Court of Chancery Explains Jurisdiction Despite Declaratory Judgment

Posted In Jurisdiction

Doe v. Coupe,  C.A. No. 10983-VCP (July 14, 2015)

It is often contended that the availability of a declaratory judgment in Superior Court to determine the parties’ rights may deprive the Court of Chancery of jurisdiction to grant an equitable remedy such as an injunction. After all, it is assumed that the parties will obey the decision of the Court in deciding their rights. More ›

Superior Court Extends Jurisdiction Under The Director Long Arm Statute

Ting v. Silver Dragon Resources, Inc., No. 14C-12-067 WCC (June 3, 2015)

It is conventional wisdom that the director long arm statute only confers jurisdiction for breaches of fiduciary duty. Yet as this decision points out, that limitation is not firmly grounded in the words of the statute. Hence, this decision may expand the sort of claims for which a director may be subject to Delaware court jurisdiction when the tort or other claim  is only “related and predicated” on conduct that implicates a breach of fiduciary duty.

Court Of Chancery Confirms Jurisdiction Over Escrows

East Balt LLC v. East Balt US LLC, C.A. 10462-VCN (May 28, 2015)

There are often disputes over funds held in escrow under earn out or indemnification provisions in various deals. This decision confirms that the Court of Chancery will take jurisdiction over a suit seeking specific performance of the distribution provision of the escrow agreement. This seems particularly desirable because that Court has the most experience with why such escrows are put in place and has resolved many such disputes in the past.

Court Of Chancery Retains Suit After Martinez Ruling

Posted In Jurisdiction

VTB Bank v. Navitron Projects Corp,. C.A. 8514-VCN (April 28, 2014)

After the Delaware Supreme Court's Martinez decision dismissing a case on forum grounds, some thought that Delaware might reject other cases as well. This decision limits Martinez's scope and makes it clear that Delaware entities will be subject to Delaware jurisdiction in the circumstances where the activities of the entity "implicates [the Court of Chancery's] fundamental and immutable responsibility to supervise the entities chartered and formed under Delaware law."  While that mandate is clearly limited to some set of cases less than the universe of disputes a corporation may be subject to, what is covered remains to be seen.

District Court Clarifies Who Is A Manager

Posted In Jurisdiction

Wakley Limited v. Ensotran LLC, C.A. 12-728-GMS (March 18, 2014)

Under the Delaware LLC Act, a manager or a person who acts like a manager is subject to jurisdiction in Delaware in a breach of duty case arising out of her management.  Because the LLC agreement usually sets out who is a "manager," that is usually not disputed.  However, it is often less clear who had exercised management duties sufficient to be subject to jurisdiction in Delaware. This decision helps decide that question. It points out that just being named an officer is not enough to submit to jurisdiction and that the nature of the defendant's' duties compared to what it is alleged she did improperly may also be determinative.  In other words, if you "managed" X project but are sued for what you did on the Y project, there is no jurisdiction over you..

Court Of Chancery Clarifies Jurisdiction

Posted In Jurisdiction

Darby Emerging Markets Fund L.P. v. Ryan,  C.A. 8381-VCP (November 27, 2013)

This decision clarifies the Court of Chancery's jurisdiction under the clean up doctrine and when a contract subject to specific performance has not yet been breached.

Court Of Chancery Explains Conspiracy Jurisdiction

Posted In Jurisdiction

Lake Treasure Holdings Ltd. v. Foundry Hill GP LLC, C.A. 6546-VCL (November 21, 2013)

The so-called conspiracy theory of jurisdiction over a non-resident is often misunderstood. This decision is useful because: (1) it explains the relationship between jurisdictional discovery and the burden of alleging facts sufficient to establish jurisdiction and (2) it again explains what must be shown to warrant jurisdiction under the conspiracy theory.

Court Of Chancery Explains Limits Of Jurisdiction Over Foreign Entities

Posted In Jurisdiction

Baier De Adler v. Upper New York Investment Companies LLC, C.A. 6896-VCN (October 31, 2013)

This is an interesting decision dealing with jurisdiction over foreign entities. The Court will not take jurisdiction when the assets involved are located outside the US and not owned by a Delaware entity

Court Of Chancery Again Explains Conspiracy Theory Of Jurisdiction

Posted In Jurisdiction

Microsoft Corporation v. Amphus, Inc., C.A. 8092-VCP (October 31, 2013)

The alter ego and conspiracy theories of jurisdiction are among the hardest to understand.  This decision carefully and clearly applies those theories to a complicated fact pattern.